Blog Aggregation Taken Too Far

This post by Mike Laverick is, as I believe they say, spot on (did I get my British English right?). Blog aggregation is one thing; many bloggers do it, including myself in my Virtualization Short Takes. VMware does it with Planet V12n. It’s not that uncommon. In my opinion, as long as the original blogger and the original blogger’s website are properly and clearly attributed, it’s not really a big deal.

The site that Mike pointed out, however, is—in my opinion—taking blog aggregation too far. There’s no clear attribution of the original author nor a clear link back to the author’s original site. I recognize content there from RTFM Education and Yellow Bricks for sure, and I suspect that some of the other sites in the Blogroll are also being rolled in. At no point anywhere in any of the aggregated articles do I see a link back the original author, the original author’s site, not even so much as mention of the original author’s name. There is only a small byline that says “By: Other Website”, but that’s it.

If you want to aggregate content, feel free. Just be sure to give credit where credit is due, and don’t rip off other people’s content.

Tags: ,

  1. Mike Laverick’s avatar

    Yes, your british english is spot on. Looks like my little joke worked. My blog about blog as winded up on his site. So he must just have script to do this – and doesn’t even bother to read the posts – so he’s too lazy to even select the content for his readers…

  2. slowe’s avatar

    I understand how you feel, Mike…I ran into the same issue a short while back:

    http://blog.scottlowe.org/2008/04/22/stolen-content/

    It’s infuriating to have someone replicate your content without even so much as a mention as to who really produced it! I hope that bringing attention to this matter will help fix it.

  3. Jason Boche’s avatar

    RTFOB

    Read
    The
    F…… (choose your version)
    Original
    Blog

  4. Aaron Delp’s avatar

    Hey Scott – That is the site that I told you about a few months ago in the office. I posted a comment over there to please stop using my posts or at least clearly state where the posts were coming from.

    Instead of other site, it used to say “contributor”. I never contributed anything to them. After a back and forth with the site author a few changes were made but I noticed my content isn’t there anymore.

    I agree, I don’t like the way the site is set up.

  5. slowe’s avatar

    Aaron,

    I remember we talked about it, but I didn’t remember the name or URL of the site. Looks like the maintainer of the site has moved on to new targets.

    Jason,

    Aggregation in and of itself is not a bad thing…just when content isn’t appropriately attributed. When properly attributed, it will draw traffic back the original blog, as it should.

    Thanks for reading!

  6. Duncan’s avatar

    I also noticed this a while ago. Haven’t got a clue who this is and they never asked me if they could repost my stuff.

  7. benjamin’s avatar

    I fully agree with Mike on this issue.

    A few days, I was shocked to see a replica of Duncan’s post on that page.

  8. Vinf’s avatar

    Yeah I’ve noticed they’ve been doing the same to my blog as well..

  9. Aaron Delp’s avatar

    In case you haven’t seen, the author has taken the site private. A userid and password is now required to view the site. Just an FYI…

  10. slowe’s avatar

    Thanks for the heads up! Looks like a little publicity was all we needed. Great work, everyone!